PANZAR Forum
http://forum.panzar.com/

Weekly Comics Contest IV - Community Vote (Split Vote 1/2)
http://forum.panzar.com/viewtopic.php?f=45&t=13191
Page 2 of 2

Author:  Headquarters [ Fri Oct 10, 2014 12:21 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Weekly Comics Contest IV - Community Vote (Split Vote 1/

White Wolf wrote:
Heardquarters,

It is impossible to do right by everyone. If you look at every game show on TV the public gets to vote. In a public vote you have 3 kind of voters.

1 the ones that vote for real
2 the ones that vote for friend
3 the ones that vote for friend of friend just to get that extra vote.


In TV shows you need multiple SIM cards to vote multiple times, at least it cost you a few Euros, time (to purchase them), rarely happens that one has got 11 mobile phones already by his/her side and the community is much much much larger than our little-going-to-be-none-community. 11 extra votes in TV shows would not buy you the ticket to heaven. However, 11(just a random number) accounts cost no money and unlimited number of accounts and therefore votes can be arranged.

Quote:
Quality does matter I don't look at spelling, but if I don't understand what has been write by grammar mistakes it is a problem.
If I read the comics and I don't smile you done get in my top 3.

Ok! Although I don't remember me questioning YOUR judgement?! The problem is that "I" can vote myself 100 times and earn 33% of the votes while my submission may lack all the quality factors. Why this should even be a possibility! You say that's insignificant, I say that can rank you up from being 4th to become 3rd and win you crystals.

Quote:
I want everyone to be happy, 1ste comics was 6 judges and I got the comment that is was unfair that the community didn't get a vote and that to many from the russian office got to vote.

You got 1 comment from Gandalf (http://forum.panzar.com/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=13153) and even he later (go to 2nd page) clarified what he meant. You also asked about this voting system of yours from me and Taser and we both could picture and foreseen today's problems exactly how they are. I wonder based on how many complains this new, non-practical solution has been offered! (That's not a question)

senjorpomidor wrote:
Guys, don't blame Wolfie in all sins )
He is doing a great job for us.


There is no doubt that he is doing great and I for one, has always been thankful. If my proposition on how to make the voting system more fair, sounds disrespectful or it hurts people's feelings, I deeply apologize.

Maybe it's time to lock all the forum posts and use it as a news board.
Anyway this was the last complain you hear from me regarding this mater.

Author:  OusterR [ Fri Oct 10, 2014 12:22 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Weekly Comics Contest IV - Community Vote (Split Vote 1/

Anyway I think, the only admins should judge.
This would be the most fair ;)

Author:  White Wolf [ Fri Oct 10, 2014 12:52 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Weekly Comics Contest IV - Community Vote (Split Vote 1/

I'm just stating what I think, I don't take it personally. You need to tell me what is on your mind because if you don't tell I don't know.

Keep on posting everyone has there opinion.

I'm keeping the system as it is for now.

Just if you vote for something that is realy not funny the chance is still small you get something.

Author:  Rin the Hateful [ Fri Oct 10, 2014 2:45 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Weekly Comics Contest IV - Community Vote (Split Vote 1/

Make a system where every participant must send a PM to White Wolfs with his vote for another comic. So only those who are active have voting rights, no self-vote options, but in exchange everything is, or could be, public.

But no systems are perfect, there's always something that's missing a piece...

Page 2 of 2 All times are UTC + 1 hour [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/